To Each Their Own (Opinion).
Dentists March 27th, 2007
Ignorance is bliss isn’t it. I feel sorry for this commenter’s patients. This is an answer to this question at Yahoo Answers.
HeatherS, you I suppose you are expecting an answer from me.I don’t how how long ago you graduated from dental school, so perhaps you’ve been in practice so long that you’ve just learned to accept the status-quo.
There is a horrendous problem in the dental profession, both at the educational level and the pratical level. There are ten different kinds of dental doctors, 9 of whom deal with problems almost exclusively within the confines of the mouth–a hole in the head the size of a tennis ball. Obviously, there’s not much turf to go around, so what happens? 1. you get a lot of overlap between the jobs of specialists, and 2. you get specialists who isolate their practices to very few types of problems and procedures.
Take endodontists for example. There is absolutely no justification for their existence. None whatsoever. How do I know this? Because the scope of their work is exceedingly limited (root canals, endo retreatments, post spaces, apexification procedures, and apicoectomies), . So limited in fact, that it could easily be incorporated into a dental school curriculum for general dentists to learn. Certainly, any general dentist (with a little bit of practice) can learn to do all of these procedures. I did.
The fact of the matter is that there are general dentists who don’t know how to do it and don’t want to learn, Why? Because they don’t want to bother with it and because they know they can make more money performing crown and bridge. And of course, there are plenty of endodontists who are just happy to feed off these lazy, greedy dentists, doing root canals day in and day out at literally 150% or more the cost of a root canal performed by a general dentist.
This approach does not serve the dental profession well. It makes us look absolutely ridiculous! The fact that a patient who comes in with an endodontic tooth problem and cannot be treated by his dentist sounds preposterous. Moreover, it doesn’t serve the patient well.
If you’re too incompetent to do your own molar endo with similar speed and quality as an endodontist, you shouldn’t have a license to practice dentistry.
I am also a firm believer that periodontics and orthodontics should not exist either. These are services that general dentists should be able to perform as well. How do I know this? Because there are many general dentists who perform all of their own perio surgeries and general dentists who handle all of their own ortho!
Same with prosthodontics and pedodontics.
With the exception of oral and maxillofacial surgery and oral path, none of the dental specialties are sciences that are diverse enough to warrant doctors who study them exclusively (the way a cardiologist studies cardiology, or a plastic surgeon studies plastic surgery, or an ENT studies the head and neck). Endodontics, ortho, pedo, prosth are all tiny disciplines that can easily be incorporated into the scope of a general dentists practice.
But they’re not. Why? Because everyone with a DDS or DMD is interested in making money…especially the specialists. And the schools are more interested in preserving the work-load for the specialists by keeping their students ignorant of anything but the most basic endo, pedo, prosth, and teaching them absolutely nothing about ortho.
Think about it this way, Heather: what type of work is unique to the general dentist? Fillings. That’s it. That is the only kind of work we do for which there isn’t a specialist.
This doesn’t strike you as absolutely ridiculous?
DR. SAM & DR. ALBERT:
Dr. Sam, you said it yourself: you don’t do molar endo because it “disrputs your schedule” and because the endodontist can do it faster. Ask yourself this: what if endodontists didn’t exist? General dentists would become more competent at molar endo! And, patients wouldn’t be charged the specialist premium for a procedure that a general dentist OUGHT to be able to do!
Dentistry should consist of three types of doctors: general dentists, oral pathologists, and oral surgeons. Why do I say this? Because there are general dentists who treat kids, perform ortho, perform all their molar endo, perform their own perio surgery, their own prosthodontic work, etc. Oral pathologists cover the diseases of the oral cavity and maxillofacial region, and oral surgeons are there to handle the more involved surgeries (i.e. orthognathics, vestibuloplasties, pathology, etc.). Between these three doctors (if general dentists were trained PROPERLY in dental school), everything within the dental profession would be covered. Everything. But that will never happen because there are too many general dentists who are perfectly content sticking with the money-making routine work and too many specialists perfectly content doing root canals and sedating kids day in/day out for obscenely high fees.
I perform the majority of my third molar extractions, virtually all of my preprosthetic surgeries, and 99.999 percent of my extractions of surgically-erupted teeth. I also treat many children, and when I get training to sedate patients, I will treat all of my pediatric cases. I also perform virtually all of my own endo, referring to endodontists the cases that are borderline hopeless (and often turn out to be untreatable).
I am am under 5 years in private practice, mind you. I have a long way to go in my career and thus plenty of time to learn to do the things we general dentists SHOULD have been taught in school.
The poster tried to suck me into a pointless argument here.
March 27th, 2007 at 6:47 am
WHAT and ignorant bloody dickhead.
They certainly seem to have tickets on themself.
People with that sort of attitude are an embarassment to the profession and probably more motivated by money rather than a passion for the work they do.
March 27th, 2007 at 7:15 am
i’m speechless…with LAUGHTER!
how can i possibly take this shit seriously? it ranks right up there with the opposite end of the spectrum – i once had an ortho resident say that he would never go to a general dentist for anything, and he would even see a prosthodontist for a filling because only a prosthodontist would “find the balance of occlusion.” these guys should get together and sling their crap at one another.
why are the majority of dentists such dickheads? i have a post coming up about some events that have transpired over the last few weeks that will expound on this.
March 27th, 2007 at 7:23 am
Yay! According to the poster, I’m relevant! Huzzah!!!
(I have to say, that Yahoo site gives me nose bleeds. So much uninformed, cringingly uneducated answers interspersed with the occasional gem of truth. It’s like searching for diamonds in manure.)
March 27th, 2007 at 8:26 am
Even though I got fucking pissed when I read that guy’s crap (I assume the poster is a guy) I still managed a smile when I realised Looking_Down’s relevance to the post.
August 26th, 2007 at 9:03 pm
Quote: “I am am under 5 years in private practice, mind you. I have a long way to go in my career and thus plenty of time to learn to do the things we general dentists SHOULD have been taught in school.”
That’s a proper attitude. I wish you all the best.
Dr Sasha
June 15th, 2008 at 9:48 am
[...] so often I think about the idiot dentist that we wrote about in this post a while back. For some reason he is one of the few things that aggravates the hell out of me. It is [...]