Written on the referral slip that arrived with this patient was a note from their dentist, “Please perform apical surgery.”

I suppose the dentist was concerned about the post being irretrievable. My concerns were the probable coronal leakage that was causing the apical lesion and the fact that apical resection of the root would put me up against the end of the post — leaving me in a difficult position for a retrofilling. Apical surgery will not hold up against coronal leakage in a predictable fashion.

Assuming that the dentist could do a crown with a decent coronal seal, why not take the post out and retreat the root canal work? Retreatment would offer a more predictable solution for the tooth.

Ah, but a deep screw post like this is quite daunting to remove. We worry about the risk of fracturing or perforating the root.

Here’s what your average neighborhood endodontist should be able to do for you:

Microscopes, ultrasonic instruments, and training allow us to deal with cases like this in a conservative, predictable fashion. Orthograde retreatment of cases like these are viable options and should be presented to patients. Jumping straight to the surgical option is a disservice to your patient.

Update (August 14th, 2008): Here’s the post-op film: